Asset Owners Unimpressed with ESG Toolkit

According to a survey by ESG data provider GaiaLens, just 23% of asset owners (AOs) are happy with ESG index providers, while many are dissatisfied with data and ratings services. Over a quarter said ESG index providers’ methodologies were “unclear” or “not robust”, with more than one in five considering the “accuracy of existing ESG scoring and rating systems” to be a to be a major concern. Nearly one in five AOs said more evenly balanced indexing of all ESG factors is needed, as many currently focused too heavily on climate. Thirty-six percent were concerned about social and environmental data gaps from their asset managers, while 14% of AOs said index providers were not “focusing on the areas of ESG which most concern us”.  Nearly 16% think ESG indexes are delivering investment performance “below what our investors expect”. Gordon Tveito-Duncan, GaiaLens co-founder, said: “Environmental data over recent years has left [AOs] exposed in terms of the S & G performance reporting. Four in every five of the largest asset owners were experiencing data quantity or quality issues and/or struggling to establish a consistent, uniform method of valuing and scoring the ESG performance of their portfolios.” 

To Top
Newsletter SignupReceive all the latest stories from the ESG Investor editorial team

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter below and never miss a story.